How many times have I heard the famous C. F. W. Walther quote - the closer to Luther, the better the theologian?
Walther is held up as a guru by Synodical Lutherans; this pastor even said that the closer one is to Walther, the better is the theologian.
There is one example of fanatic if you ever want to find one.
During Walther's controversy on the doctrine of election, learned men frequently quoted to Walther the fathers of the Lutheran church. Here is what Walther said, you can find the full quote in here.
The principal means by which our opponents endeavor to support their doctrine, consists in continually quoting passages from the private writings of the fathers of our Church, published subsequent to the _Formula of Concord_. But whenever a controversy arises concerning the question, whether a doctrine is Lutheran, we must not ask: "What does this or that 'father' of the Lutheran Church teach in his private writings?" for he also may have fallen into error;
Those words of Walther are an epitome of the quip - take my advice, I am not using it.
In reality, what Walther really meant in practice was - the closer to Luther, the better the theologian, unless, the theologian teaches against me (because the said theologian must be in error).
The words in red are my interpretation of his behaviour on how he handled criticism. In fact his UOJ followers have the same attitude towards their critics... they must be wrong.
When a person falls for a fallacy, one does not stop at swallowing just one fallacious argument. The person invariably swallows the next one and the one after that and so on and on.
Here is another Walther quote from this site and IMHO, shows that Walther and Huber were cut from the same cloth.
We are not reconciled to God when we believe, but we are already redeemed, are already reconciled to God, so that we believe. This is also true regarding justification. The whole world is already justified in Christ. Faith is not the condition under which we are justified but the way and means by which we become partakers of the justification which God has long ago given us
There is the fallacy of misreading Romans 4:25.
A fish is caught through its mouth.